Publication
Road to COP29: Our insights
The 28th Conference of the Parties on Climate Change (COP28) took place on November 30 - December 12 in Dubai.
Climate risk management: An overview of recent key developments for financial institutions
Canada | Publication | November 1, 2024
On July 4, 2024, the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF, Quebec’s financial services regulator) published the final iteration of its “Climate Risk Management Guideline” (the Guideline). The Guideline's objective is to strengthen the resilience of the financial sector and the financial institutions it regulates regarding the impacts of climate change.
The Guideline applies to licensed insurers, financial services cooperatives, licensed trust companies and other licensed deposit-taking institutions under the AMF’s jurisdiction, but does not apply to reporting issuers generally. Going forward, the institutions subject to the Guideline are expected to consider climate-related risks as part of their integrated risk management processes.
Following the precedent established by the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), the AMF incorporated and supplemented the most recent recommendations from standard-setting bodies regarding climate risk disclosure. These include the IFRS S1 (general requirements) and S2 (climate-related requirements) standards developed by the International Sustainability Standards Board. In the insurance sector, the International Association of Insurance Supervisors recommendations and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision principles for effectively managing and monitoring climate-related financial risks were also considered by the AMF.
The Guideline puts in place a timeline, which starts applying to financial institutions for their fiscal year 2024 or 2025 depending on how they were categorized by the AMF – the AMF used several indicators, including the size, level of complexity and net assets of the financial institutions. In July 2024, all concerned financial institutions should have been informed of their categorization by an e-mail from the AMF.
This article summarizes the expectations set out in the Guideline, the upcoming phases in applying the Guideline, as well as the interplay with the popular IFRS S1 and S2 voluntary standards.
Importing from, but also expanding beyond, the most popular voluntary disclosure frameworks
The Guideline integrates the IFRS S1 and S2 standards with tailored adjustments for the financial sector. This is a forced deviation from the AMF’s initial strategy to align with the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), which has officially been disbanded to be replaced by the IFRS S1 and S2 standards.
As a result, any financial institution captured by the Guideline that previously reported in accordance with the TCFD framework will have a few adjustments to make – mainly, adding to the existing disclosure. How extensive will this effort be?
To this end, the IFRS Foundation has released a comparison of the requirements under IFRS S2 and the recommendations of the TCFD.1 Essentially, the IFRS S2 standard builds upon the TCFD recommendations by introducing new requirements, including requirements for companies to disclose industry-based metrics, to disclose information about their planned use of carbon credits to achieve their net greenhouse gas emissions targets and to disclose additional information about their financed emissions.
Moreover, as further explained below, the Guideline goes beyond the original scope of the TCFD recommendations or IFRS S1 and S2 standards by introducing two additional pillars that are more specific to financial institutions, namely: (i) capital and liquidity adequacy; and (ii) the fair treatment of clients.
AMF expectations pursuant to the Guideline
In its Guideline, the AMF indicates its expectations pertaining to climate-related risks and opportunities under six pillars:
1. Governance: within the scope of its responsibility, the board of directors is expected to demonstrate competence and independence in its assessment of climate-related risks. It is the board of directors' responsibility to ensure climate risk issues and challenges are taken into account when drawing up major action plans, integrated risk management policies, annual budgets and performance targets, when monitoring progress against objectives and targets, and when developing compensation policies for senior management and other key positions. The roles and responsibilities of executives should also be clearly defined.
The financial institution should consider the impact of climate change and the transition to a low-carbon economy in its strategy. To this end, the financial institution should implement a transition plan that aligns with its business plan, strategy, and risk appetite. This transition plan should serve as a guiding framework for managing physical2 and transition3 risks associated with a low-carbon economy.
2. Integrated risk management: strategies, policies and procedures should be put in place to effectively identify and assess climate change-related risks, and to manage those risks in accordance with the integrated risk management framework, transition plan, and risk appetite of the financial institution. The financial institution should establish a climate change-related risk mitigation plan and maintain regular monitoring and reporting on internal targets regarding its risk management.
3. Climate scenarios and stress testing: the financial institution should analyze climate scenarios to assess the impact of climate risks on its risk profile, strategy and business model over an appropriate time horizon. This analysis should take the form of an assessment of plausible future situations and the risk exposure related to them. Furthermore, the financial institution should conduct standardized climate scenario analysis and, upon request, provide the results to the AMF.
On this point, we also note that OSFI published the Standardized Climate Scenario Exercise, on September 10, 2024. This document explains how federally regulated financial institutions and federally regulated pension plans can complete standardized climate scenario exercises and report their results to OSFI. Considering the collaboration between OSFI and AMF on climate change matters, this document could be relevant for a financial institution in meeting the Guideline’s expectations.
4. Capital and liquidity adequacy: while conducting its internal capital adequacy assessment process, the financial institution should consider the impact of climate-related risks. It should maintain an adequate level of capital and liquidity to ensure the coverage of its exposure to climate change-related risks.
5. Fair treatment of clients: the financial institution should consider the climate-related risks throughout the entire lifecycle of a product it offers, and keep clients informed of potential risks related to transition risks and the impact of extreme weather events. In line with its risk appetite, the financial institution should design products adapted to the risks associated with climate change and consider elements such as the needs and interests of its various target client groups, and an appropriate product withdrawal or modification process.
The Guideline states the underwriting process should be updated regularly to take into account climate change-related risk factors as well as the special needs of certain customer groups.
It is also the responsibility of financial institutions to ensure customers are provided with clear and accurate information regarding the potential climate change-related risks associated with the products they are considering purchasing.
6. Climate-related financial risk disclosures: in regard to communication, the financial institution should publicly disclose, on a consolidated basis, its key governance and integrated risk management elements, as well as its climate scenarios and crisis simulations related to climate change.
The AMF has established five principles for effectively communicating climate risk information: (i) it should be relevant, specific and comprehensive; (ii) it should be clear, balanced, and understandable; (iii) it should be neutral; (iv) it should be appropriate to the financial institution's size, nature, and complexity; and (v) it should be consistent with the financial institution’s other publications.
It is the financial institution's responsibility to provide climate change-related financial disclosures in a report to shareholders, if it is public, or in a separate report if it is not.
It is expected that financial institutions will make disclosures pertaining to their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and climate change-related risk management targets and will assess their performance in relation to these targets.
OSFI’s Guideline B-15 Climate Risk Management, published in March 2023, essentially covers the same elements as the AMF’s guideline, but the latter also covers the fair treatment of clients. Federally regulated institutions subject to the Guideline will thus be subject to a similar regime in Quebec, with some additional requirements.
Timeline for applying the guidance regarding communicating information about climate change
Appendix 1 of the Guidance sets the timeline for minimal expectations regarding the communication of information about climate change, for both insurers and deposit-taking institutions. Such reporting is due 180 days after the fiscal year-end, at the latest. The table below summarizes information contained in this appendix.
Considering that the expectations outlined in the Guidance are quite extensive and will apply in the coming years, financial institutions should become familiar with them and start planning their implementation accordingly.
|
Timeline for minimal expectations regarding the communication of information about climate change |
|||
| Information category |
Communication expectations |
Group A |
Group B |
| Governance | a) Description of the governance bodies (e.g., board of directors, committees) or the individuals responsible for overseeing climate change-related risks and opportunities, including their responsibilities. b) Description of the role of management in monitoring, managing and overseeing climate change-related risks and opportunities, as well as of the controls and procedures in place. |
a) 2024 b) 2024 |
a) 2025 b) 2025 |
| Strategy | a) Description of identified risks and opportunities that could impact cash flows and financing. b) i Description of the impact of climate change on business model, value chain, strategy, decision-making, financial positions, financial performances and cash flows. b) ii Description of the financial institution’s climate transition plan. c) Description of the resilience of the financial institution’s strategy, taking into account different climate scenarios. |
a) 2024 b) i 2024 b) ii TBD c) TBD |
a) 2025 b) i 2025 b) ii TBD c) TBD |
| Risk Management |
a) Information on the processes and policies used to identify and monitor climate-related risks. b) Information on the processes used to identify and monitor climate-related opportunities. c) Information about the integration of processes used to identify and monitor climate change-related risks and opportunities in the financial institution’s overall risk management system. |
a) 2024 b) 2024 c) 2024 |
a) 2025 b) 2025 c) 2025 |
| Metrics and targets |
a) Disclosure of metrics used to assess climate-related risks and opportunities. b) i Disclosure of the financial institution’s Scope 1 and location-based Scope 2 absolute gross GHG emissions, as well as description of how they were calculated – See GHG Protocol Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard. b) ii Disclosure of the financial institution’s Scope 3 absolute gross GHG emissions, as well as description of how they were calculated. Specific calculations apply depending on business lines and types of assets – See GHG Protocol Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard. c) Disclosure of quantitative and qualitative targets set to monitor progress towards achieving its strategic goals, as well as related information. d) Disclosure of certain cross-industry metrics. e) Disclosure of certain industry-based metrics. |
a) 2024 b) i 2024 b) ii 2025 c) 2024 d) 2025 e) 2025 |
a) 2025 b) i 2025 b) ii 2026 c) 2025 d) 2026 e) 2026 |
Ontario Securities Commission provides overview of its approach to sustainable finance
On October 7, 2024, the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) published “Insights on the OSC Staff’s Approach to Sustainable Finance,” in which it outlined its objectives and areas of activities regarding sustainable finance. This includes regulatory work, compliance oversight, education, research, engaging with stakeholders, and monitoring international developments in this field.
Currently, the OSC seems to take a more flexible approach to sustainable finance than does the AMF. Indeed, its framework is less specific and does not include an implementation timeline.
The fact that, contrary to other provincial regulators, the AMF does not share regulatory authority over financial institutions may be a factor as to why the AMF can more freely impose discrete disclosure obligations on financial institutions. We also note the OSC mentions various initiatives that will come to fruition in the future, so more developments are expected in Ontario.
On October 9, 2024, the Canadian government published a news release mentioning its intent to amend the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) to include climate-related disclosure obligations for large private CBCA corporations. A regulatory process will be launched to determine the substance of those obligations. Consult our recent legal update for more information on this topic.
Footnotes
2
Physical risks refer to the direct consequences of an increase in the frequency, unpredictability and severity of extreme weather events.
3
Transition risks are generated by the transition to a low-carbon economy. This transition may be characterized in particular by new government policies, by changes in the decisions and behaviour of the various players involved, or by the arrival of new substitute technologies.
Recent publications
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .