![Global rules on foreign direct investment](https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/-/media/images/nrf/nrfweb/knowledge/publications/us_24355_legal-update--fdi-alert.jpeg?w=265&revision=a5124a65-abf9-40e4-8e96-9df39ffdb212&revision=5250068427347387904&hash=96B456347C3246E5649838DF281C5F5D)
Publication
Global rules on foreign direct investment (FDI)
Cross-border acquisitions and investments increasingly trigger foreign direct investment (FDI) screening requirements.
Global | Publication | settembre 2022
Earlier this year, the Mexican Ministry of Energy (SENER) issued an official communication (SENER's Communication) addressed to the National Center of Natural Gas Control (CENAGAS) and the Energy Regulatory Commission (CRE), aimed at implementing a new policy that creates additional rules for the provision of natural gas transportation services by CENAGAS through the Mexican national transportation system known as SISTRANGAS.
As outlined in our recent publication on the matter, in summary, SENER's Communication:
As a direct response to SENER's Communication, the Mexican Federal Economic Competition Commission (COFECE) issued a non-binding opinion advising against the implementation of SENER's Communication. COFECE reasons, among other arguments raised throughout its opinion, that:
COFECE's opinion was directly addressed to the heads of SENER, CRE and CENAGAS, urging them to (i) refrain from implementing SENER's Communication; and (ii) abide by the applicable legal principles of free market, open competition and open access.
While as noted COFECE's opinion is non-binding in nature, COFECE in its capacity as constitutionally-independent agency, also filed a federal constitutional control claim (controversia constitucional). COFECE's claim was mostly predicated on the same arguments raised under its opinion and, consistent with the Mexican rules of constitutional control procedure, COFECE petitioned for an injunction to be issued in order to prevent the application of SENER's Communication.
The claim brought by COFECE will be heard by Mexico's Supreme Court of Justice (SCJN). As part of the proceedings, earlier this month the SCJN granted the injunction requested by COFECE, thus suspending – with general effects – the application of SENER's Communication and any implementing actions for SENER, CRE and/or CENAGAS. Effectively, this means that until the merits of COFECE's constitutional claim are conclusively resolved, the revised natural gas strategy mandated by SENER's Communication cannot be implemented and no party (e.g. SISTRANGAS users or other natural gas permit holder) may be required to comply with the requirements of SENER's Communication.
SCJN expressly noted that the injunction was granted to maintain the status quo during the pendency of the claim and until a final resolution is issued, as allowing SENER's Communication to be implemented prior to ruling on its constitutionality may cause "irreparable harm" and/or materially affect the economic competition in Mexico, inter alia, due to the extensive requirements that SISTRANGAS users would be required to meet to comply with the new natural gas policy. In any case, SCJN also noted that granting the injunction does not prejudge on the constitutionality (or lack thereof) of SENER's Communication.
COFECE's constitutional claim marks the latest instance of COFECE strongly positioning against other controversial changes brought by the Mexican Government in the energy sector. You can read more about it here: New policy in Mexico puts dagger in private sector participation in the electricity sector, Mexico’s Federal Economic Competition Commission on the amendment to the CFE terms of legal separation, Mexican ISO prevents wind and solar projects from reaching commercial operation and Mexican Competition Commission criticizes actions against wind and solar projects.
Publication
Cross-border acquisitions and investments increasingly trigger foreign direct investment (FDI) screening requirements.
Publication
Artificial intelligence (AI) raises many intellectual property (IP) issues.
Publication
We are delighted to announce that Al Hounsell, Director of Strategic Innovation & Legal Design based in our Toronto office, has been named 'Innovative Leader of the Year' at the International Legal Technology Association (ILTA) Awards.
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2023