
Publication
ESG and internal investigations: New compliance challenges
As ESG concerns have come to the forefront in different jurisdictions, the scope of these inquiries is expanding in kind.
Global | Publication | April 2025
On April 17, the Office of the United States Trade Representative’s (USTR) released its Notice of Action and Proposed Action in Section 301 Investigation of China’s Targeting the Maritime, Logistics and Shipbuilding Sectors for Dominance, Request for Comments (the Notice). The Notice:
The Notice responds to the findings of the USTR’s Section 301 Investigation of China’s Targeting of the Maritime, Logistics and Shipbuilding Sectors for Dominance.1 Section 301 grants the USTR the authority to investigate and remediate certain foreign trade practices. In February 2025, the USTR published its Proposed Action in Section 301 Investigation of China’s Targeting of the Maritime, Logistics and Shipbuilding Sectors for Dominance (the Initial Proposal), which proposed, among other things, levying significant port fees on Chinese vessels. Following this, the USTR accepted public comments on the proposal, with public hearings concluding March 26. On April 9, 2025, the White House issued Executive Order 14269, “Restoring America’s Maritime Dominance” (the Order). Among other things, the Order instructed the USTR to consider additional tariffs against Chinese-built cargo handling equipment, including ship-to-shore cranes.
The Notice consists of both the USTR’s final determinations on the Initial Proposal as well as new proposed actions in response to the Order. The comment period for the new proposal opened on April 17, 2025. Requests to appear at a hearing on the new proposal should be submitted by May 8, 2025 and written comments should be submitted by May 19, 2025. Comments may be submitted for up to seven days after the last day of the public hearings.
The Notice includes four annexes consisting of three service fees and one set of vessel requirements. The Notice provides that a vessel will only be subject to “(a) one of the three fees directed under Annex I, II or III; or (b) a requirement under Annex IV.” As such, a vessel may be subject to one or more of the annexes, but will only ever be subject to one of the penalties provided in Annex I-IV.
In determining which of the annexes apply, the Notice provides the following rules:
Annex I applies service fees to Chinese owned and operated vessels.2 For purposes of determining applicability of the fee, a vessel’s owner and operator are the entities identified as such in the Vessel Entrance or Clearance Statement (Form 1300) filed with US Customs and Border Protection (CBP).To evaluate whether the owner oroperator listed on Form 1300 qualifies as being Chinese, the Notice draws on concepts of legal title, beneficial ownership and effective control. Specifically, a vessel will be considered to have a Chinese owner and/or operator, which generally includes the People’s Republic of China, Hong Kong and Macau for the purposes of Annex I, if the vessel’s owner or operator:
LNG vessels subject to Annex IV and car carriers subject to Annex III are exempt.
The vessel’s operator must calculate, report and pay the Annex I service fee, as well as provide any requested supporting documentation, through existing government methods specified by CBP prior to the entry of the vessel into a US port on a particular string. However, the Annex I service fee will only be charged at the first port of call within a string of US port calls and will only be charged a maximum of five times per year, per vessel. Though the operator initially pays the fee, the operator may seek reimbursement from contractual counterparties.
The Annex I service fee will be set at the following rates on the following dates:
Fee | Effective date |
---|---|
US$0 per net ton for the arriving vessel | April 17, 2025 |
US$50 per net ton for the arriving vessel | October 14, 2025 |
US$80 per net ton for the arriving vessel | April 17, 2026 |
US$110 per net ton for the arriving vessel | April 17, 2027 |
US$140 per net ton for the arriving vessel | April 17, 2028 |
To any Chinese-built vessel that is not exempt. A vessel is considered a Chinese-built vessel under Annex II if it was built in the PRC, consistent with the definition of “place of build” in CBP and US Coast Guard (USCG) regulations and would be so identified on the Form 1300.
Annex II only applies to Chinese-built vessels that are not Chinese owned/operated (Annex I), vehicle carriers (Annex III) or LNG carriers (Annex IV). Further, the following Chinese-built vessels are exempt from the Annex II fee:
Additionally, CBP will suspend the applicable fee for a particular vessel for up to three years if the vessel owner orders and takes delivery of a US-built vessel (as defined by the Annex) of equivalent or greater net tonnage relative to the vessel which would be subject to the Annex II fee.3
The vessel owner is responsible for paying any applicable fee through existing government methods specified by CBP. However, the Annex II service fee will only be charged up to five times per year, per vessel. The vessel owner may seek reimbursement from contractual counterparties including charterers and cargo interests.
The applicable Annex II service fee charged to the vessel owner will be the greater of the fee determined by the (i) tonnage of cargo discharge or (ii) fee per container.
The Annex II service fee will be set at the following rates per net ton of cargo for the arriving vessel. on the following dates:
Fee | Effective date |
---|---|
US$0 | April 17, 2025 |
US$18 | October 14, 2025 |
US$23 | April 17, 2026 |
US$28 | April 17, 2027 |
US$33 | April 17, 2028 |
The Annex II service fee will be set at the following rates per discharged container of the arriving vessel on the following dates:
Fee | Effective date |
---|---|
US$0 | April 17, 2025 |
US$120 | October 14, 2025 |
US$153 | April 17, 2026 |
US$195 | April 17, 2027 |
US$250 | April 17, 2028 |
Annex III applies service fees to foreign-built vehicle carriers. For the purposes of Annex III, a vehicle carrier is a vessel which is principally identified as a “Vehicle Carrier” on Form 1300. A foreign-built vessel is any vessel which is not a US-built vessel, as defined in Annex III.4
CBP will suspend the Annex III service fee for up to three years if the vessel owner orders and takes delivery of a US-built vessel of equivalent or greater Car Equivalent Unit (CEU) relative to the vessel which would be subject to the Annex III fee.
The vessel operator must calculate, report and pay the Annex III service fee through existing government methods specified by CBP and provide any requested supporting documentation. The operator may seek reimbursement for the fee from contractual counterparties.
The Annex III service fee will be set at the following rates for the following dates:
Fee | Effective date |
---|---|
US$0 | April 17, 2025 |
US$150 per CEU capacity of the entering non-US built vessel. | October 14, 2025 |
Annex IV sets restrictions on the percentage of LNG which must be exported using qualified US-built vessels. The restrictions come into effect after three years on April 17, 2028. USTR plans to consult with the Department of Energy (DOE) and other agencies to provide industry additional notice and technical information regarding this restriction. Commencing on April 17, 2028, 1 percent of US vessel-borne LNG exports must be shipped on US-flagged and US-operated (but not US-built) vessels. Commencing on April 17, 2029, 1 percent of US vessel-borne LNG exports must be shipped on US-built, US-flagged and US-operated vessels. That number gradually increase to 15 percent by April 17, 2047.
CBP will suspend the applicable fee for up to three years if the vessel owner orders and takes delivery of a US-built vessel of equivalent or greater LNG capacity, measured in cubic feet, relative to the vessel which would be subject to the Annex IV penalty.
Beginning in the third year (April 16, 2028), LNG terminals must report to the DOE the LNG shipments, and percentage of LNG shipped, on US-flagged, US-built and US-operated vessels. If the targets of Annex IV are not met, then USTR may direct the suspension of LNG export licenses.
Under Annex IV, the percentage of LNG which must be exported by US-built vessel by each date is as follows:
Required exports by vessel | Restrictions | Effective date |
---|---|---|
0% | N/A | April 17, 2025 |
0% | N/A | April 17, 2026 |
0% | N/A | April 17, 2027 |
1% | US-flagged vessel and US-operated | April 17, 2028 |
1% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2029 |
1% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2030 |
2% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2031 |
3% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2032 |
3% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2033 |
4% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2034 |
4% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2035 |
6% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2036 |
6% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2037 |
7% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2038 |
7% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2039 |
7% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2040 |
9% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2041 |
9% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2042 |
11% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2043 |
11% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2044 |
13% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2045 |
13% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2046 |
15% | US-built, US-flagged and US-operated | April 17, 2047 |
The Notice proposes tariffs on Chinese ship-to-shore cranes and other cargo handling equipment, identified below, as required by Executive Order 14269, “Restoring America’s Maritime Dominance” (the Order).
Annex V proposes the following duties on the following products of China:
Item | Proposed tariff rate |
---|---|
Containers | 100% |
Chassis | 100% |
Chassis parts | 100% |
Ship-to-shore gantry cranes5 | 100% |
As mentioned prior, the comment period for the new proposal opened on April 17, 2025. Requests to appear at a hearing on the new proposal should be submitted by May 8, 2025 and written comments should be submitted by May 19, 2025. Comments may be submitted for up to seven days after the last day of the public hearings.
Section 301 Investigation: Report on China’s Targeting of the Maritime, Logistics, and Shipbuilding Sectors for Dominance, January 16, 2025.
A vessel is considered Chinese owned or operated for the purposes of Annex I, if it has an owner or operator: (i) whose country of citizenship is identified as the People’s Republic of China (PRC), Hong Kong, or Macau on the Vessel Entrance or Clearance Statement or its electronic equivalent; (ii) whose headquarters, parent entity’s headquarters, or parent entity’s principal place of business is the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau; (iii) is owned by, or controlled by, a citizen or citizens of the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau; (iv) is owned by, controlled by, or subject to the jurisdiction or direction of the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau, including where: (a) the entity is a national or resident of the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau; (b) the entity is organized under the laws of or has its principal place of business in the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau; (c) 25 percent or more of the entity’s outstanding voting interest, board seats, or equity interest is held directly or indirectly by any combination of the governments of the PRC, Hong Kong, or Macau;(d) 25 percent or more of the entity’s outstanding voting interest, board seats, or equity interest is held directly or indirectly by any combination of the persons who fall within clause (iv)(a)-(c); (iv) is owned by, or controlled by, an entity listed as a Chinese Military Company pursuant to Section 1260H of the William M. (“Mac”) Thornberry National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 (Public Law 116-283); or (vi) is an ocean common carrier, as defined in 46 U.S.C. § 40102(7), that is, or whose operating assets are, directly or indirectly, owned or controlled by the government of the PRC or any of its political subdivisions, with ownership or control by a government being deemed to exist for a carrier if: (a) a majority of the interest in the carrier is owned or controlled in any manner by the government of the PRC, an agency of the government of the PRC, or a public or private person controlled by the government of the PRC; or (b) the government of the PRC or any of its political subdivisions has the right to appoint or disapprove the appointment of a majority of the directors, the chief operating officer, or the chief executive officer of the carrier.
A vessel meets the requirements of a US-built vessel for the purposes of Annex II if: (i) the vessel is built in the United States; (ii) the vessel is documented under the laws of the United States; (iii) all major components of the hull or superstructure of the vessel are manufactured (including all manufacturing processes from the initial melting stage through the application of coatings for iron or steel products) in the United States; and (iv) the following components of the vessel are manufactured in the United States: (a) air circuit breakers; (b) welded shipboard anchor and mooring chain; (c) powered and non-powered valves in Federal Supply Classes 4810 and 4820 used in piping; (d) machine tools in the Federal Supply Classes for metal-working machinery numbered 3405, 3408, 3410 through 3419, 3426, 3433, 3438, 3441 through 3443, 3445, 3446, 3448, 3449, 3460, and 3461; (e) auxiliary equipment for shipboard services, including pumps; (f) propulsion equipment, including engines, propulsion motors, reduction gears, and propellers; (g) Shipboard cranes; (h) spreaders for shipboard cranes; (i) rotating electrical equipment, including electrical alternators and motors; (j) Compressors, pumps, and heat exchangers used in managing and re-liquefying boil-off gas from liquefied natural gas.
A vessel meets the requirements of a US-built vessel for the purposes of Annex III if: (i) the vessel is built in the United States; (i) the vessel is documented under the laws of the United States; (iii) all major components of the hull or superstructure of the vessel are manufactured (including all manufacturing processes from the initial melting stage through the application of coatings for iron or steel products) in the United States; and (iv) the following components of the vessel are manufactured in the United States: (a) Air circuit breakers; (b) Welded shipboard anchor and mooring chain; (c) powered and non-powered valves in Federal Supply Classes 4810 and 4820 used in piping; (d) machine tools in the Federal Supply Classes for metal-working machinery numbered 3405, 3408, 3410 through 3419, 3426, 3433, 3438, 3441 through 3443, 3445, 3446, 3448, 3449, 3460, and 3461; (e) auxiliary equipment for shipboard services, including pumps.
Ship-to-shore cranes subject to the duty include any such products: (i) which are products of China; and (ii) of which one or more of the following components, assembly, or sub-assembly of the ship-to-shore crane are products of China: (a) the main boom; (b) the trolley; (c) the spreader; (d) the cabin; (e) the legs; (f) the cable reel; (g) the power supply; (h) the bogie set and wheels; and (i) any information technology equipment.
Publication
As ESG concerns have come to the forefront in different jurisdictions, the scope of these inquiries is expanding in kind.
Publication
In compliance with the constitutional reforms published in the Federal Official Gazette, new secondary legislation regulating the energy sector, specifically in terms of power and hydrocarbons, was published on March 18, 2025.
Publication
On February 1, US President Donald Trump signed three executive orders which impose tariffs on Canada, China, and Mexico based on declared national emergencies associated with purported illegal immigration and fentanyl imports from each country.
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2025