Publication
Mission impossible? Teresa Ribera’s mission letter and the future of EU merger review
Executive Vice President Vestager’s momentous tenure as Commissioner responsible for EU competition policy is nearing its end.
The Trade Competition Act B.E. 2560 (2017) (the Act) is administered by the Trade Competition Commission (the TCC), which is itself assisted by an administrative office (formerly the Office of the Trade Competition Commission, whose English name was recently – and somewhat confusingly – changed to the Trade Competition Commission of Thailand, the TCCT). The Act prevents restrictions of competition. In particular, the Act:
The Act prohibits joint actions (including written or verbal agreements, whether legally enforceable or not, decisions of industry associations and concerted practices) between business operators which monopolise, reduce or restrict competition. The Act distinguishes on the one hand joint actions between business operators competing with each other in the same market which cause “serious damage to competition” (i.e. hardcore horizontal agreements and practices), and on the other hand joint actions between business operators in the same or different market (as the case may be) which cause “damage to competition” (i.e. non-hardcore horizontal and vertical agreements and practices respectively).
Consistent with international practice, anticompetitive agreements and practices by business operators within a single economic entity are considered to be intragroup and shall not be caught by the prohibitions on anticompetitive agreements. Any two or more business operators that are under the same controlling interest will be considered to form a single economic entity. Pursuant to the TCC’s Notification on Rules for the Assessment of Undertakings under Common Policy Relations or Common Controlling Interests (2018) (the Rules for the Assessment of Undertakings under Common Policy Relations or Common Controlling Interests), a common controlling interest will exist where a business operator owns more than 50 per cent of the shares of another operator, or controls the majority of its voting shares, or has the right to appoint at least half of its directors.
The Act (Section 54, as supplemented by the TCC’s Notification on Guidelines for the Assessment of Collective Practices by Undertakings that are Monopolization, Competition Reduction, or Competition Restriction in Market (2018) (the Guidelines on Restrictive Joint Actions)) stipulates the following specific prohibition against hardcore horizontal agreements and practices between competing business operators in the same market, which are subject to criminal penalties:
The Act (Section 55, as supplemented by the Guidelines on Restrictive Joint Actions) prohibits the following non-hardcore restrictive joint actions between business operators whether in the same or different market (as the case may be, i.e. either horizontal or vertical agreements or practices), which are subject to administrative sanctions:
Non-hardcore joint actions may benefit from exemptions on several grounds (under Section 56 of the Act) as follows:
The Act (Section 50, as supplemented by the TCC’s Notification on Guidelines for the Assessment of Practices by an Undertaking with Dominant Position (2018)) prohibits a business operator from abusing its dominant position by engaging in the following conduct:
According to the TCC’s Notification on Criteria for being an Undertaking with Dominant Position (2020), a business operator is deemed to have a dominant position when:
The Act (Sections 51 to 53, as supplemented by the TCC’s Notification on Rules, Procedures, and Conditions for Merger Approval (2018) and the TCC’s Notification on Rules, Procedures, and Conditions for Notification of Merger Transaction (2018)) implements a dual merger control regime:
The prohibited practices (under Section 57 of the Act, as supplemented by the TCC’s Notification on Guidelines for the Assessment of Unfair Trade Practices (2022)) include:
Infringements of the Act can attract both administrative and criminal sanctions. Throughout 2021, the TCC had imposed several administrative fines but had not attempted to seek criminal penalties.
In respect of non-hardcore arrangements, unfair trade practices and agreements with offshore operators, administrative sanctions may be imposed by the TCC (see Section 82 of the Act). Fines of up to 10 per cent of the annual turnover in the year of the infringement may be imposed. If the offence is committed in the first year of the business, the administrative sanction will not be more than one million baht (approx. US$30,000).
Administrative sanctions can also be imposed on violation of the merger control provisions (see Sections 80 and 81 of the Act):
Criminal sanctions will only apply to hardcore horizontal arrangements or abuses of a dominant position (see Section 72 of the Act). The maximum criminal sanction is two years’ imprisonment or a fine of 10 per cent of the annual turnover in the year of the offence, or both. If the offence is committed in the first year of the business, the imprisonment sanction remains the same but a fine will not be more than one million baht (approx. US$30,000).
Consistent with competition law regimes elsewhere, an agreement made or a conduct that occurred in a foreign country will be caught by the Act as long as it affects the Thai market. The Act (Section 58) also expressly prohibits agreements between domestic and offshore operators which could create a monopoly or unfair trade restrictions and cause severe damage to the Thai economy and consumer as a whole.
The competition authority responsible for enforcing the Act is the TCC, as well as the TCCT, its administrative office.
The TCC has the power to investigate, issue orders and decisions and impose administrative sanctions against parties involved in anticompetitive agreements, abusive practices, unfair trade practices or unreasonable offshore agreements. It also has power to investigate, approve and reject mergers and acquisitions as well as imposing administrative sanctions on failing to notify reportable transactions.
For criminal sanctions, the TCC shall refer the case to the public prosecutor for prosecution before the Intellectual Property and International Trade Court. If the district public prosecutor issues a non-prosecution order, the TCC may request the case to be further considered by the Attorney General.
There is no recognition of leniency in the Act or any implementing regulations.
The TCC has broad investigation powers under the Act, similar to those of police officers under the Thai Criminal Procedure Code. It can issue subpoenas requesting any persons to provide both oral and written information, and conduct raids on premises of the business operators or other relevant persons to search and seize evidence for examination (see Section 63 of the Act).
Sanctions for non-compliance with the TCC’s investigations can lead to a maximum imprisonment of one year and a maximum fine of 20,000 baht (approx. US$650) (see Sections 73 and 74 of the Act).
Throughout 2021, the TCC published 29 cases on its website. Among the decisions, there were only three decisions where the TCC ordered an administrative fine against the offenders, while the TCC found in the remaining 25 decisions that there were no violations of the Act. The total amount of administrative fines ordered by the TCC was of around 4.8 million baht (approx. US$160,000).
In terms of merger control, 8 decisions of the TCC were published on its website in 2021. The TCC approved all transactions without conditions, including 6 cases that were notified post-merger and 2 cases that were notified pre-merger.
Trade Competition Act B.E. 2560 (2017)
5th floor, Car Parking 5th floor Building(BC), The Government Complex,
120 Chaeng Wattana Road, Thungsong-hong Sub-district,
Laksi District, Bangkok 10210
Thailand
Tel: +66 2199 5400
Website: www.tcct.or.th
Members of the Trade Competition Commission: Professor Sakon Varanyuwatana (Chair), Mr. Krisda Piampongsant (Vice Chairman), Mr. Santichai Santawanpas (Spokesman), Mr. Somchart Sroythong, Mr. Somkiat Tankrittiwat, Pattama Teanravisitsagool and Mr. Raksakecha Chaechai.
Secretary-General of the Trade Competition Commission: Mr. Somsak Kiatchailak
Publication
Executive Vice President Vestager’s momentous tenure as Commissioner responsible for EU competition policy is nearing its end.
Publication
On November 28, 2023, the European Commission (EC) adopted its first list of Projects of Common Interest (PCIs), i.e., projects within the EU territory, and Projects of Mutual Interest (PMIs), i.e., projects connecting the EU with other countries, including 166 projects implementing the European Green Deal.
Publication
On 10 October 2024, the UK government published its long awaited response (the Response) to its January 2024 consultation on “Designing a policy framework to enable investment in long duration electricity storage” (the Consultation).
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2023