Publication
The Art of Dispute: Key case law and recent developments in dispute resolution
Our newsletter provides practical advice and a concise analysis of key case law and recent developments in dispute resolution.
More opportunities for foreign investors?
Global | Publication | February, 2016
For foreign investors, foreign investment restrictions for basic telecom and value-added telecom services still continue to apply. However, it is anticipated that the approval process to obtain appropriate licences may be expedited for foreign investors wishing to set up subsidiaries in China to conduct business there (especially for e-commerce and offshore call centre activities, in respect of which foreign investment entry barriers have been fully removed on a national basis).
The Shanghai Free Trade Zone will continue to act as an attractive option for foreign investors to set up a presence in China in order to conduct value-added telecom and internet services. If they set up a subsidiary in the Shanghai Free Trade Zone, foreign investors can take the benefit of additional relaxation of certain market entry requirements in some sectors, such as information services (limited to Apps store), store and forward services, onshore call centres and multi-party telecom services.
Telecommunications services in China are classified into two broad categories: basic telecommunications services (BTS) and value-added telecommunications services (VATS), each of which is further classified into various sub-categories (as set out in the Classification Catalogue of Telecommunications Services).
Under the telecommunications regulations, telecom and internet service providers are required to apply for licences for each sub-category of services they may provide. Applications are made to MIIT (or its local counterparts), which is the licence-issuing authority empowered to publish service-specific licensing regulatory rules and to amend the Catalogue as required.
On 24 December 2015, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology’s (MIIT) issued the Classification Catalogue of Telecommunications Services (2015 Catalogue), which will officially take effect as of 1 March 2016.
The 2015 Catalogue demonstrates MIIT’s intention to strengthen the regulation of China telecom and Internet services, and provides a much needed update of the 2003 version. New technologies (such as cloud computing, big data and various types of information service) have been included in the 2015 Catalogue for the first time. The changes introduced by the 2015 Catalogue are likely to have an impact upon both domestic and foreign businesses. It will be crucial for foreign telecom and internet service providers which have entered (or which aspire to enter) the Chinese telecom and internet market to understand the changes introduced by the 2015 Catalogue, and to address their significance in practice.
Type II VATS are based on the “public application platforms”, which are mostly provided to public end customers and are more closely concerned with personal data protection issues. Type II VATS include, among others, the following services:
Under the 2015 Catalogue, online data processing and transaction processing services and domestic multi-party real-time communication services (which used to be Type I VATS) are now re-categorised as Type II VATS. On the other hand, internet access services (which used to be Type II VATS) are now re-categorised as Type I VATS.
MIIT adopts a diverging approach when granting licences for Type I and some Type II VATS. Therefore it is important for businesses to examine closely MIIT’s practical treatment of the Type I and Type II VATS when applying for a VATS licence under the 2015 Catalogue.
For Type I VATS, MIIT is likely to apply more stringent criteria when granting licences (given that the services have implications for national information security and social order). MIIT will typically take into account concerns reflected in the Anti-Terrorism Law and the Cyber Security Law (which is currently still in the draft form, but will be finalised soon) when reviewing applications for Type I VATS licences.
For Type II VATS, however, the situation appears to be different. Advances in technology and innovation within the internet sector have typically been equated with Type II VATS. MIIT has introduced service-specific regulations and has fully opened up some of the Type II VATS (that is, online data processing and transaction processing services for e-commerce operations and offshore call centre services) to foreign investors. In effect this reduces market entry requirements for those services which fall under Type II VATS.
The 2015 Catalogue does not directly impact upon the scope of telecommunications and internet services a foreign investor may provide in China. This is because the existing restrictions imposed on international businesses by the China Telecommunications Regulations and the Regulations on Administration of Foreign-invested Telecommunications Enterprises continue to apply, restricting the percentage of shares or equity held by a foreign investor to no more than 49% for BTS and no more than 50% for VATS.
The Shanghai Free Trade Zone has promoted a pilot scheme since January 2014. Under it, foreign investors can benefit from additional relaxations of foreign ownership restrictions for selected VATS services (such as information services (limited to Apps store), e-commerce, store and forward services, call centres and multi-party communications services).
The ongoing move towards liberalisation of China’s telecom and internet market is particularly apparent in the full opening up of two areas of activity to foreign investment on a national basis: online data processing and transaction processing (for e-commerce operations) and offshore call centre services. In these areas foreign investors are permitted to hold up to 100% of shares or equity. This change was introduced by service-specific legislations published by MIIT before the 2015 Catalogue was issued.
The 2015 Catalogue provides more regulatory clarity to the range of services that has emerged in recent years as well as laying a foundation for MIIT to issue more service-specific regulations to address more opportunities for foreign investment. Such liberalisation will be of particular interest to foreign investors, who should take into account new service-specific policies introduced by MIIT before exploring new investment opportunities in China’s telecommunications sector.
In the meantime, businesses which currently operate in China should be mindful of the changes introduced by the 2015 Catalogue. From 1 March 2016 onwards, the MIIT will grant licences for telecommunications services in accordance with the 2015 Catalogue. Licences granted to existing licence holders prior to that date will continue to be valid within the stipulated scope and for the full term of the relevant licence. However, existing licence holders must nevertheless review their current business practices and apply for a new licence if any of their existing services become subject to the licensing requirements under the 2015 Catalogue.
Publication
Our newsletter provides practical advice and a concise analysis of key case law and recent developments in dispute resolution.
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2023